Eva Tilling wakes up in the hospital to discover an attempt has been made on her life. But who in her sleepy town could have hit her with their car? And why? Before she can consider the question, she finds that she's awoken with a strange new skill: the ability to foresee people's deaths when they touch her.

While she is recovering from the hit-and-run, Nate, an old friend, reappears, and the two must traverse their rocky past as they figure out how to use Eva's power to keep her friends - and themselves – alive. But the killer is obsessed and will stop at nothing to get to Eva…

No spoilers ahead.

An Advanced Reader's Copy of this book has been graciously provided by HarperCollins UK in exchange for an honest review.

If you haven't heard about Made For You by Melissa Marr, it's most likely because you know it under its alternate name. Made For You was originally titled This Is Why We Need More YA Crime/Mystery In Our Lives. If it still doesn't ring a bell, then go ahead and pick it up. Melissa Marr, known for her fantasy Wicked Lovely series, ventures out into the world of YA contemporary (with a dash of magical realism) in Made For You, and it's everything we could have hoped for, and more.

In dual narrative, this story alternates between the POV of a girl who survived an attempt at her life, and the actual killer who was responsible for it. And it's every bit as bone-chilling, and every bit as exciting as it sounds. Following this attempt at her life, Eva Tilling's high school friends find themselves in danger equal to the one Eva herself was in, and often a lot less lucky in terms of the outcome. Which is how Eva finds herself racing to figure out the identity of a killer in her midst, and one whose every kill somehow traces back to her.

While as reviewers we often find ourselves questioning:
a) why an author opted for a dual narrative in the first place;
b) especially when the voices are virtually indistinguishable,
this is by no means the case here. Melissa Marr does an eerily brilliant job of deconstructing the mind of a killer, and the voice that comes out is one so genuine that it simply makes this book in more ways than one. Once upon a time, while watching The L Word, my favorite actress of the lot was repeatedly accused of "playing a psycho too well". It was an accusation which always made me bristle, because - my god - that only makes her better. And at long last, I have found said actress's equivalent in writing. It's Melissa Marr's take on a schizophrenic serial killer's perception of reality, with all the (il)logical reasoning one might expect - and a whole lot more one might not expect - from a YA mystery.

Which is why we need so, so much more of it in our lives.

Sure, the final revelation isn't quite as shocking as an Agatha Christie novel - the reader is, in fact, openly allowed to figure it out before the protagonist does - it is still one which brings about an explosive resolution to the story, with all the twists and turns the build-up promises to deliver.

And these twists, these turns, these twisted minds and eerie thoughts all take place in Small Town, Deep South - in just about the perfect setting, in other words, for this type of a story. It's atmospheric, it's foreboding, it's expectation and chill and mounting pressure. It's hard to decide if the setting establishes the plot, or the other way round. Melissa Marr has just married the two so well that it's hard to imagine Made For You taking place anywhere else.

For all thrill-seeking readers, fans of mystery, thrillers or magical realism of any sort, Made For You is my sincerest recommendation. But it is also my sincerest recommendation to read it in broad daylight - just to be on the safe side. It's not exactly horror, but this book makes it easy to argue that an insight into a twisted mind rivals the goriest novels in terms of "I'll just sleep with the lights on tonight".

Consider me hooked on YA mystery. And Nathaniel Bouchet, but that's completely beside the point.

If you are planning on picking this book up - or if you have already read it - leave us a comment below and let us know what you thought of it. Or you can social-media-stalk us - which is the only kind of stalking we approve of! (Hey, this book is frightening, don't blame us!)



4/ 5

Subscribe via email

Like what you see? Add your email to subscribe.


Write comments
17 October 2015 at 06:06


I love to read and I am a huge Melissa Marr fan. I am surprised I have not heard of or seen this book. Each time I go into a bookstore, I immediately look for Melissa Marr books to see if she has published any new books, or if I can stumble upon books I have never read. One of my friends introduced me to the Wicked Lovely series a few years ago, and I am hooked. Melissa Marr is a great author and writer and I cannot help but let my imagination get the best of me each time I read her books. I have to say that your review of Made for You by Melissa Marr was very interesting, and it definitely has my engaged in wanting to purchase the book myself. “Eva Tilling wakes up in the hospital to discover an attempt has been made on her life,” was the first sentence that had me intrigued; I am a sucker for mysteries. Thank you for this review!

17 October 2015 at 21:40

Hello, Katrina! Since you love both mysteries and Melissa Marr, I really don't see how this book could fall short for you. :) I was given an ARC earlier this year even though the book was officially out, so it could be that the first release was somehow mishandled and it got a re-release at some point in 2015. That would explain how it could go unnoticed by the fans. But one way or another, what I said I meant - this book makes it abundantly clear that we need more YA mystery in our lives. And as this one alternates between the victim's and the killer's perspective (and it's done so well!), well... that sets the bar pretty high.

Thank you very much for stopping by!